So I did something I often do when I see these sorts of policy discussions. I opened an AI chat discussion and asked it questions about history and policy in other countries. Things that I could probably research for myself and I sort of know, but it helps to have comprehensively surveyed for me. Through a series of questions I tried to nail down if any legislature in any country has ever stopped a war started by the executive. I even said, okay, look at parliamentary systems too. The historical results are not great.
I think the closest it was able to find was France in 1954 with the National Assembly forcing an end to the first Indochina war under any terms. But honestly, that was about it!
There's been better luck with "prior restraint" with the executive having to seek legislative approval before deploying troops. But of course that's never going to work with the United States which has forward-deployed troops all over the world who can be ordered to act at any time by the President.
What I'm saying is that this doesn't seem like an easy problem that all the other nations of the world except the dum-dum United States can easily solve. Or I guess the solution is, don't have troops all over the world and a world-spanning Navy. Because if you do, it's pretty hard to stop the President from using them, especially if he decides he doesn't care how unpopular it is.
It may be a little difficult to word, but I think that we should be allowed to defend our bases if attacked, but we should not be able to do any aggression unless Congress has declared war. Presidents always seem to make the excuse that they need to be able to act quickly, but Congress declared war on Japan less than a day after Pearl Harbor, and that was in 1941 with much worse technology. I'd be fine with remote voting for Congress generally, and especially for emergency votes like a war declaration. The president shouldn't be allowed to send aircraft, ships, or soldiers out to attack anyone with whom we're not in a declared war.
The way to have the legislature keep the executive from starting stupid wars is to make it so that if the executive starts a stupid war, the legislature can remove the executive by simple majority vote.
Everyone wants Congress to be able to rein in the President except for a majority of the primary voters of the President’s party
So I did something I often do when I see these sorts of policy discussions. I opened an AI chat discussion and asked it questions about history and policy in other countries. Things that I could probably research for myself and I sort of know, but it helps to have comprehensively surveyed for me. Through a series of questions I tried to nail down if any legislature in any country has ever stopped a war started by the executive. I even said, okay, look at parliamentary systems too. The historical results are not great.
I think the closest it was able to find was France in 1954 with the National Assembly forcing an end to the first Indochina war under any terms. But honestly, that was about it!
There's been better luck with "prior restraint" with the executive having to seek legislative approval before deploying troops. But of course that's never going to work with the United States which has forward-deployed troops all over the world who can be ordered to act at any time by the President.
What I'm saying is that this doesn't seem like an easy problem that all the other nations of the world except the dum-dum United States can easily solve. Or I guess the solution is, don't have troops all over the world and a world-spanning Navy. Because if you do, it's pretty hard to stop the President from using them, especially if he decides he doesn't care how unpopular it is.
It may be a little difficult to word, but I think that we should be allowed to defend our bases if attacked, but we should not be able to do any aggression unless Congress has declared war. Presidents always seem to make the excuse that they need to be able to act quickly, but Congress declared war on Japan less than a day after Pearl Harbor, and that was in 1941 with much worse technology. I'd be fine with remote voting for Congress generally, and especially for emergency votes like a war declaration. The president shouldn't be allowed to send aircraft, ships, or soldiers out to attack anyone with whom we're not in a declared war.
The way to have the legislature keep the executive from starting stupid wars is to make it so that if the executive starts a stupid war, the legislature can remove the executive by simple majority vote.