11 Comments
User's avatar
Testname's avatar

I’ll say it: yes, America is unique relative to most countries in having birthright citizenship…which is why we are unironically BETTER THAN THEM. If the countries of Europe and Asia and Africa allow a class of people to be born, live their lives, and die while excluding them from full citizenship, then I am prepared to judge them harshly.

lin's avatar

“We should be more like Europe and less like America”—a thing it would never occur to these people to say in any other context…

Anssi's avatar

Birthright is not unique to the United States, it's common in the western hemisphere. The only thing unique to you is your narcissism.

Ben's avatar

"Relative to most countries".

Brian T's avatar

For any other Roguelike fans, I encourage people to check out Nethack! They just release 5.0.0 a few months ago!

Zac Hill's avatar

One reason projects like The Argument are important is that so many successive generations have basically been underexposed to the normative origins of the liberal tradition, such that there is this entire genre of ‘just asking questions’ policy analysis which assumes that any given idea is best evaluable exclusively at the object level. But liberalism as a tradition is one rooted fundamentally in the desire to constrain power. Birthright citizenship is one of many examples of policies where the primary intention is power constraint - which does indeed involve tradeoffs, another near-forgotten political constant.

Longestaffe's avatar

Thank you for this powerful essay.

Subcommander Tal's avatar

Birthright citizenship has worked well for us so far, and maybe it always will. When I hear about people like Xu Bo and Michael Wei Yueh Liu, though, I wonder. Those are outliers of course, but they are a reminder that principles conceived for a particular time and place may not scale for a future where technology and movement of peoples have become qualitatively different. Many Americans would like to revisit the Second Amendment. Many would like to revisit birthright citizenship.

I loathe Trump and would welcome some legal technicality we might otherwise ignore to see him neutralized and defanged. From the Right’s point of view That is what they are doing to Omar.

Bob Eno's avatar

I support automatic birthright citizenship, Subcommander. My reasons are much the same as those stated by Jerusalem Demsas and Milan Singh -- no need to repeat. But I think your comment is truly thoughtful because you point to (1) unquestionable potential for abuse, (2) the idea that Constitution is a document of limited wisdom that in a better world would be revisable as conditions change, (3) we need to understand how these issues are viewed by people with views different from our own.

I'd disagree with your implication that the Second Amendment issue is similar to birthright citizenship: I believe it is the reverse. The essential nature of the initial clause of the Second Amendment (linking the right to bear arms to the need for militias) was a settled interpretation for a century and a half; it was gun-rights activists who executed a sustained campaign to revisit and reinterpret the Amendment, bypassing the amendment process. Those who support gun control generally want to restore the traditional reading of the Amendment unless the text is revised through amendment. In the case of the 14th Amendment, Trump's executive order attempted to do a similar end run past the amendment process, exploiting the political make-up of the Supreme Court. In this case the result was a failure. (More generally, the "originalist" impulse was certainly spurred by overreach of the Warren Court, and its most careless members -- in my view: I'm thinking specifically of Douglas and Black -- but it is quite clear that originalism can equally serve as a verbal cover for a different type of politically driven carelessness.) . . . Despite its length, this paragraph is not as responsive to your excellent comment as my shorter one.

Bob Eno's avatar

When it comes to the uniqueness of the US's automatic birthright citizenship, I believe that, in fact, this is the norm in the Western hemisphere: Canada and Mexico in North America, all of Central America except Costa Rica, all South American countries other than Colombia, Paraguay, Chile, and Suriname (it seems to be less common in the Caribbean).

Evil Socrates's avatar

I agree that the investigation is 100% for sure and for true politically motivated. However, this essay should have spent more time on whether it has any likely merit and how we should think about it if it does have merit.

If, heaven willing, Democrats end up with the levers of power in 28, you can be sure they will be prosecuting a lot of misconduct by former Trump officials--some of which will be obviously illegal, some of which will be grey area, and some of which will be ticky tack stuff like this (and, arguably, like the campaign finance stuff they already tried to tag him with). Should we likewise regard all that enforcement as illegitimate "Nazi shit"? How do you thread the needle of politicians being answerable for crimes vs pretextual "anti corruption" crackdowns you see abroad?