The Argument

The Argument

The Opening Argument

The best — and worst — midterm candidates, by the numbers

The WAR scores for 2026 are in

Lakshya Jain's avatar
Lakshya Jain
Nov 19, 2026
∙ Paid
Texas Democrat James Talarico won his Senate seat by so much that his coattails carried congressional candidates who were never expected to win. (Illustration by The Argument using ChatGPT; photo by Adam Gray/Getty Images)

Is Generation Z screwed? With unemployment barely over 4%, even asking that question might elicit eye rolls in some quarters. But on this week’s episode of The Argument podcast, Jerusalem Demsas and Matt Yglesias were joined by economics commentator Kylan Scanlon, who is uniquely sympathetic to the plight of the young. Paid subscribers can watch or listen to the episode ad free or read the transcript. Free subscribers can watch the episode on YouTube or listen at their podcast provider of choice.

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Overcast | Pocket Casts


If you’ve seen Moneyball (or read the book), you’re probably familiar with the concept of Wins Above Replacement (WAR). In baseball, WAR tells you how much value a player adds to their team by quantifying how many “wins” the player contributes over a generic replacement-level player at the same position.

As part of our work at Split Ticket, we’ve spent years calculating WAR for political candidates. Today, we’re proud to introduce our WAR model — exclusively here at The Argument — for the 2026 midterm elections.

Share

Here’s how we calculate each score: For every single contested two-party race, our model compares the final result to the expected result of a matchup between a generic Democrat and generic Republican in the same district. The difference between the actual result and the generic baseline tells you whether the Republican or the Democrat in the race was stronger — and by how much.

For instance, let’s consider Mississippi’s U.S. Senate race, in which Democrat Scott Colom narrowly prevailed over incumbent Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith. Because baseline voting patterns in Mississippi are so Republican to begin with, a “generic” matchup between an incumbent Republican and a Democratic challenger probably would have produced something like a 6-point Republican win — even in a blue wave year like 2026.

Instead, Colom won by roughly 1 point. Thus, the WAR for that race is D+6.6 — meaning, in our estimation, that Colom did 6.6 points better against Hyde-Smith than you would expect a standard Democrat to do against a standard Republican incumbent.

A model like this is incredibly hard to make, especially in a midterm year. Many basic analyses simply compare 2026 results to 2024 presidential margins. But a Democrat outperforming Kamala Harris by 30 points in Houston isn’t nearly as impressive as the very same 30-point overperformance in rural Mississippi would be.1 That’s because you have to take into account factors like the demographics of the seat, incumbency and outside party support, and the statewide environment.

This is the most complex and comprehensive modeling exercise we’ve done yet. Let’s dive into the findings.

Become a free subscriber to see the full WAR 2026 scorecard

Democrats really overperformed in the Senate

Want to see which candidates actually moved the needle? Who earned their coattails and who dragged their party down? Paid subscribers get the ranking, WAR by district, full analysis, and what it all says about Democrats’ path to 2028.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to The Argument to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Jerusalem Demsas · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.