The Argument

The Argument

The Opening Argument

Why is progress so unpopular?

My trip to a gathering of techno-optimists left me wondering about progress’s PR problem

Jeremiah Johnson's avatar
Jeremiah Johnson
Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid
New York World’s Fair Futurama exhibit. April 22, 1939. (Illustration by The Argument/ChatGPT; Photo by Bettmann via Getty Images)

To attend the Progress Conference, an annual confab hosted by the nonprofit Roots of Progress, is to be surrounded by people who believe in a better tomorrow, and who are personally determined to make it happen. It’s an inherently optimistic place, and one that makes me feel more hopeful about the future of society every time I go.

The “progress movement” that the conference is intended to represent is a bit amorphous— it overlaps with slightly more well-defined efforts like Abundance, YIMBYism, rationalism, and effective altruism — but at its core it’s filled with people who believe that economic growth, technological innovation, and human ingenuity can make the world a better place.

At this year’s Progress Conference, which was hosted in Berkeley in October, I talked with policy experts trying to build high-speed rail faster, solar technology entrepreneurs, philosophers trying to grapple with what humanity would look like if we ever conquered aging, and an eclectic mix of scientists, wonks, investors, and academics all trying to push society forward.

But no matter how exciting any of these efforts seemed, there was one thought I couldn’t shake: Progress doesn’t seem very popular.

Artificial intelligence and the data centers needed to power it are deeply unpopular. More than two-thirds of Americans say they’d be uncomfortable riding in a driverless car. Far more people say that lab-grown meat will be bad for society than good, and the public opposes even researching the idea of many geoengineering efforts. It seems like everywhere you look, there’s a new technology that the public either disapproves of or outright fears.

And even when the public at large doesn’t disapprove, technology often inspires fierce opposition from a dedicated minority of critics. Nuclear power and vaccines both draw intense criticism, and organized groups exist to stop advances in those areas. New housing and new infrastructure projects often draw huge protests and face years of bureaucratic blockage to get off the ground.

As someone who sympathizes with the progress movement, it’s hard for me to grapple with the idea that in many cases these smart, hardworking, idealistic people who want to make the world a better place are pushing ideas that the public will meet with shrugs at best — and lawsuits at worst.

I went to the 2026 Progress Conference to find out if the people inside the progress movement understand why.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to The Argument to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Jerusalem Demsas · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.