Excellent article - thanks! Dogma, and the love of dogma in all its varied forms, constitute obstacles to human growth and development. A key aspect of mental and emotional maturity is the ability to note and address the operational effects of our own dogmatic ideologies and embrace the growth that arises when we finally move beyond those rigidities of thought. The main challenge we face in facilitating this growth process is our anxious discomfort with uncertainty in the absence of dogmatic belief.
Something I think your breakdown of the major polluting firms brings light upon is the role of openness to disconfirming evidence. When we feel like we’ve figured it all out already - at the animating mission level of our lives - there’s no reason to go and find what we might be missing.
I strongly agree with this as a worldview. The base, earth, nature, world that we live in is fundamentally cruel and uncaring. The only exceptions are ones that humans carve out for ourselves. Most modern cruelties are in spite of capitalism and globalization, not because of.
I don't know about 'cruel' as that somehat implies a degree of intention but uncaring quite certainly. Since the first cellular life form 3 billion odd years ago figured out eating another one alive was a fast ticket to calories....
Human romanticisation of nature is very human though.
Which is why belief systems which teach that it's humanity's fault that the world is fundamentally cruel and uncaring, that it's some just punishment because we've been bad, is so dangerous to liberalism. And to our ability to see reality.
“ No, if there is an intellectual orientation that is the enemy of liberalism, it is not conviction, but ideology.”
This statement is incredibly confused. Liberalism is an ideology with certain beliefs about human nature, how the state should work, and what society should be oriented towards. One that many people have disagreements with, some of which are worth taking extremely seriously. It isn’t merely a sort of moderate disposition. I would hope that the argument would understand this.
While I should be quite happy at the author's partial conversion to better reflection, there remain many points economic illiteracy as in " (Up to a point, at least: OPEC’s cartel behavior famously puts hard limits on how “free” the global market for oil can be.) " - the OPEC cartel decades ago lost its real control over the crude markets although the mythology of the peak influence lives on.
As a financier of renewable energy - scale RE, not retail - one of greatest current handicaps for me is the mindset he formerly had... with all the unfounded distrust of the market mechanisms (modren markets, not idealised ones of either communist nor libertarian ideologues).
However it remains that fundamentally there is a foundational error of using the classic Pollution lens to understand the CO2 problem -not only in that carbon and CO2 are really fundamental to the entire lifecycle (and not properly speaking a pollutant like, well, actual industrial pollutants, as like sulphides that led to acid raid), but are far too fundamental to basically most of the energy cycle (ex-originating from solar insolation directly or immediately [wind is in the end a solar insolation effect])
So one was always on a route to failure to try to apply pollution control concepts and mechanisms to CO2 emissions, it's always been a fundamental issue of needing technological substitution at affordable pricing for combustion (whether that combustion is stored carbon chains from ancient biological procesess that converted sunlight to stored energy or modern biologial processes that do the same [aka biomass]). And one thing free markets are damn good at as compared to alternatives is technological innovation (with it must be added good government support, i.e. old school liberal - not libertarian - market framework economic policy)
Post-evangelical here! It was just last year that certain things clicked and I started describing my professional approach (I’m a startup GC/gov affairs guy) as fundamentally Protestant - authority and power lying with the text rather than the priests, the accessibility of the text to all, etc.. The same goes for humility, which I’ve rooted for a while in the fact that I’m a *post* evangelical - irrespective of what view turns out in the end to be closer to the truth, if I could believe something so fundamental and so deeply as I did my religious upbringing yet completely change my mind about it later, then how could I ever pretend like capitalism or free speech or any other idea is inviolable? And even in law, I’m in a field where it doesn’t matter how much I know, it’s impossible for me to ever read every statute, regulation, agency interpretation, executive order, and case - I have to work knowing that at any time I could stumble upon that one piece of information , that one ruling or reg or law that completely changes my position.
When I first left christianity, I used to say my favorite people were the formerly religious as they retained critical moral foundations without being blinded by dogma or orthodoxy. I’m slowly coming back around to a similar view today. Heh.
For bonus points - how did the “woke” left turn into the religious fundamentalists I fled the right to get away from?
I assume that "liberalism" as used in this article refers not to modern liberalism but to classical liberalism, as in enlightenment principles of limited government, free markets, individual rights, empiricism, reason, etc. Modern liberalism is in large part a big stumbling block for clean energy adoption because it's so intertwined with opposition to capitalism, dislike of big business, hatred of nuclear energy, fixation on wind and solar as the only acceptable energy sources, and support for innovation-strangling regulation. It's like your house is burning down and the modern liberal approach to putting it out starts with demanding that firefighters first replace their hoses with something less carcinogenic.
To add some diversity: I'm a lapsed Catholic, rather than a lapsed Protestant
same! lol
Excellent article - thanks! Dogma, and the love of dogma in all its varied forms, constitute obstacles to human growth and development. A key aspect of mental and emotional maturity is the ability to note and address the operational effects of our own dogmatic ideologies and embrace the growth that arises when we finally move beyond those rigidities of thought. The main challenge we face in facilitating this growth process is our anxious discomfort with uncertainty in the absence of dogmatic belief.
Something I think your breakdown of the major polluting firms brings light upon is the role of openness to disconfirming evidence. When we feel like we’ve figured it all out already - at the animating mission level of our lives - there’s no reason to go and find what we might be missing.
I strongly agree with this as a worldview. The base, earth, nature, world that we live in is fundamentally cruel and uncaring. The only exceptions are ones that humans carve out for ourselves. Most modern cruelties are in spite of capitalism and globalization, not because of.
I don't know about 'cruel' as that somehat implies a degree of intention but uncaring quite certainly. Since the first cellular life form 3 billion odd years ago figured out eating another one alive was a fast ticket to calories....
Human romanticisation of nature is very human though.
Which is why belief systems which teach that it's humanity's fault that the world is fundamentally cruel and uncaring, that it's some just punishment because we've been bad, is so dangerous to liberalism. And to our ability to see reality.
“ No, if there is an intellectual orientation that is the enemy of liberalism, it is not conviction, but ideology.”
This statement is incredibly confused. Liberalism is an ideology with certain beliefs about human nature, how the state should work, and what society should be oriented towards. One that many people have disagreements with, some of which are worth taking extremely seriously. It isn’t merely a sort of moderate disposition. I would hope that the argument would understand this.
Thanks for a fantastic article! This should be public imo.
While I should be quite happy at the author's partial conversion to better reflection, there remain many points economic illiteracy as in " (Up to a point, at least: OPEC’s cartel behavior famously puts hard limits on how “free” the global market for oil can be.) " - the OPEC cartel decades ago lost its real control over the crude markets although the mythology of the peak influence lives on.
As a financier of renewable energy - scale RE, not retail - one of greatest current handicaps for me is the mindset he formerly had... with all the unfounded distrust of the market mechanisms (modren markets, not idealised ones of either communist nor libertarian ideologues).
However it remains that fundamentally there is a foundational error of using the classic Pollution lens to understand the CO2 problem -not only in that carbon and CO2 are really fundamental to the entire lifecycle (and not properly speaking a pollutant like, well, actual industrial pollutants, as like sulphides that led to acid raid), but are far too fundamental to basically most of the energy cycle (ex-originating from solar insolation directly or immediately [wind is in the end a solar insolation effect])
So one was always on a route to failure to try to apply pollution control concepts and mechanisms to CO2 emissions, it's always been a fundamental issue of needing technological substitution at affordable pricing for combustion (whether that combustion is stored carbon chains from ancient biological procesess that converted sunlight to stored energy or modern biologial processes that do the same [aka biomass]). And one thing free markets are damn good at as compared to alternatives is technological innovation (with it must be added good government support, i.e. old school liberal - not libertarian - market framework economic policy)
Post-evangelical here! It was just last year that certain things clicked and I started describing my professional approach (I’m a startup GC/gov affairs guy) as fundamentally Protestant - authority and power lying with the text rather than the priests, the accessibility of the text to all, etc.. The same goes for humility, which I’ve rooted for a while in the fact that I’m a *post* evangelical - irrespective of what view turns out in the end to be closer to the truth, if I could believe something so fundamental and so deeply as I did my religious upbringing yet completely change my mind about it later, then how could I ever pretend like capitalism or free speech or any other idea is inviolable? And even in law, I’m in a field where it doesn’t matter how much I know, it’s impossible for me to ever read every statute, regulation, agency interpretation, executive order, and case - I have to work knowing that at any time I could stumble upon that one piece of information , that one ruling or reg or law that completely changes my position.
When I first left christianity, I used to say my favorite people were the formerly religious as they retained critical moral foundations without being blinded by dogma or orthodoxy. I’m slowly coming back around to a similar view today. Heh.
For bonus points - how did the “woke” left turn into the religious fundamentalists I fled the right to get away from?
I assume that "liberalism" as used in this article refers not to modern liberalism but to classical liberalism, as in enlightenment principles of limited government, free markets, individual rights, empiricism, reason, etc. Modern liberalism is in large part a big stumbling block for clean energy adoption because it's so intertwined with opposition to capitalism, dislike of big business, hatred of nuclear energy, fixation on wind and solar as the only acceptable energy sources, and support for innovation-strangling regulation. It's like your house is burning down and the modern liberal approach to putting it out starts with demanding that firefighters first replace their hoses with something less carcinogenic.