165 Comments
User's avatar
Kevin Muldoon's avatar

In his 1941 book 'Escape from Freedom', Erich Fromm argues that modern liberty cuts people loose from the old bonds of tribe and church, and many can’t stand the silence afterward. Freedom from is easy to grant. Freedom to is hard to live. So people trade the individual self for a group identity that tells them who they are.

My thesis: the machine that builds groypers on the right also builds postliberal progressives on the left. Both are escapes from the anxiety of being an individual self. Fromm even named the exits. The right takes authoritarianism. The left takes conformity. Both deny the individual’s agency that liberal democracy runs on. Fromm was writing about the German lower middle class, not grad students. It's the same escape, wearing a different uniform.

Rick Gore's avatar

My theory is that people have a desire to express their values, and one way they did this was via religion. But with the decline of religion, a lot of people shifted to using politics instead. That’s not necessarily bad- lots of people were expressing their values by voting for Barack Obama and I would argue that worked out pretty well. But “expressing your values” can crowd out other goals. “Expressing your values” by voting for Elizabeth Warren in the 2020 presidential primary is downgrading the goal of “nominate the strongest possible candidate to beat Donald Trump.”

Fireside Patriot's avatar

I absolutely agree. If you want a book that expands on that thesis, check out The True Believer by Eric Hoffer. He dives into the role of frustration and anxiety in creating and maintaining mass movements

Robert's avatar

I can’t figure out if this is soft-headed or dishonest.

Do you really think socialism is antithetical to liberalism? That would make one of you.

Do you really think that liberalism’s central tenent is “be polite.” How dreadfully naive and inadequate.

CRT challenges notions of equality because it has thus far not existed. It doesn’t argue for inequality. It suggests you have a close look at what you think is equal because it might not be.

It also challenges objectivity because absolute metaphysical objectivity doesn’t exist and taking action in the name of objectivity has been used to create many historical injustices and atrocities. This is a central tenent of liberal philosophy for a few centuries now.

It doesn’t argue against free speech. It argues that someones response to your free speech is also free speech. And it argues that some speech is inherently harmful. Again, a central part of liberal philosophy since at least John Stuart Mill and also an inherent concept in common law since at least the 16th century.

These critiques are not liberal critiques. They are conservative critiques.

CRT is far from perfect and it is possible to find weird, awkward, or incomplete ideas in just about any philosophy, theory, movement, etc. But the idea that CRT is somehow antithetical to liberalism is downright bizarre. Just because MAGA coalesce around hating it when people talk about race is no reason to attack your own. If they really are your own.

Adam Buchbinder's avatar

“CRT doesn't argue for inequality” is a hell of a take. Arguing for race based admissions in college is unequal treatment! The thing where progressive school districts try to drag down brighter kids in the name of equity is unequal treatment!

Maybe it'll sound better coming from Ibram Kendi?

The only remedy to racist discrimination is antiracist discrimination. The only remedy to past discrimination is present discrimination. The only remedy to present discrimination is future discrimination.

“It doesn't argue against free speech. It argues that someones response to your free speech is also free speech. And it argues that some speech is inherently harmful.” That's an argument against free speech! Obviously the details matter here, but dismissing the idea that it's bad that (for example) you should lose your job and be ostracized from the community for donating to one side of a 50/50 political question is pretty illiberal! (Brendan Eich, here.)

Robert's avatar

Kendi and CRT live in the same state, but not even the same zipcode. He doesn't speak for CRT nor is the little snippet you provide a piece of CRT. I'll let ChatGPT summarize it for you:

• The Shared Ground: Both CRT and Kendi’s antiracism agree that racial disparities are caused by systemic policies and institutional power rather than biological or cultural differences between races.

• The Difference: CRT is an analytical tool used primarily to critique legal structures. Kendi's antiracism is a personal and political framework focused on action, demanding that individuals actively dismantle racist policies and evaluate their own internal biases.

It isn't uncommon to get confused and think that everybody that says "race" is the same. But it is pretty illiberal to just dismiss ideas lazily like this. Kendi came decades after the origin of CRT and does not practice or speak for CRT.

As for free speech you didn't specify which part you don't like. But it sounds like you are objecting to the idea that my response to your free speech is also free speech. So if you say or do something racist, or perhaps homophobic, you think that nobody should be allowed to post that on substack (or twitter) because you might lose your job over it? That is how Brendan Eich lost his. Suppressing people's right to express their outrage over homophobic (in this case) actions has never been a part of liberalism.

The problem with your interpretation of "liberalism" as well as that of Matthew Yglesias is that you just want it to mean what you want it to mean. Without ever actually learning what it means.

Adam Buchbinder's avatar

The original post isn't solely about CRT. It's about a generally illiberal approach to judging people as members of groups rather than as people, of which CRT is part.

I don't know why you're arguing in defense of one small part of this memeplex, and then wondering why I'm not sticking to that small corner.

Robert's avatar

You're the one who talked yourself into a corner but if you want out that is fine with me. But "judging people as members of groups" is just obtuse. Ambiguity isn't a parachute.

Classical and enlightenment liberalist philosophers like Locke and Kant championed equality and "natural rights" . . . and then excluded non-white populations lol. You aren't hoping to repeat their mistakes--mistakes which were used to justify colonialism and slavery--are you? This is exactly why CRT says we must take a long close look at what we mean by "equality."

In modern liberalism Race is understood as a product of human history, legal systems, economic exploitation, and political power dynamics rather than natural law. Which sounds a whole lot like CRT lol.

Fireside Patriot's avatar

Yes, socialism is antithetical to liberalism. The total abolition of private property runs counter to liberalism’s tenet of inalienable rights. And liberalism has produced the most abundant and properties societies while socialism has only created scarcity

Robert's avatar

Ah, so you are one of those people who get confused between communism and socialism? Communism abolishes private property (well, it has never succeeded entirely, but it aspires to). Socialism is when the fire department comes and puts out the fire at your house. Pretty compatible with liberalism lol.

Marshall Greenhut's avatar

I think you may be one of those people confused about the word meaning of socialism. Socialism, at its most basic, means the public owns the means of production - (meaning land and capital (read factories, machinery etc - everything involved in production other than labor). That’s the actual definition of socialism and the all-to-common confusion the seems to equate “socialism” with any government provision for the general welfare is actually a great example of the entryism at the heart of this piece.

Communism is a variant of socialism; the primary difference being that communism aims to socialize both production and consumption.

Broadly speaking, socialism is divided into market and non-market socialism. Market socialism maintains markets and prices to provide economic signals to the still socialized production.

There is nothing inherently socialist about a government providing for the public good, be that fire departments, social security or a modern welfare state. Food support is only socialism if the government itself owns the farms providing the food.

Social Democracy is not, in modern practice, socialism. It is a primarily capitalist system with both strong property rights and a strong welfare state and tends to aim for a more equitable distribution of income.

Robert's avatar

"Socialism is a scare word they have hurled at every advance the people have made in the last 20 years. Socialism is what they called public power. Socialism is what they called social security. Socialism is what they called farm price supports. Socialism is what they called bank deposit insurance. Socialism is what they called the growth of free and independent labor organizations. Socialism is their name for almost anything that helps all the people."

-Harry Truman

You can talk all around the issue but this is how socialism is used in the context of US politics. Social Democrats, Democratic Socialists, etc. It is about using shared wealth to build a strong society. It is not communism which is how you are trying to define it.

Fireside Patriot's avatar

Fire departments are not socialism. You seem to be confusing “when the government does stuff” and socialism. I recommend you learning about an ideology before defending it moving forward

Robert's avatar

I recommend you move past the dictionary before claiming you know what socialism is.

Adam Buchbinder's avatar

The Democratic Socialists (who you say are "to the right of Truman") do not just want the fire department to put out fires. Everyone apart from cartoon libertarians wants that. Clearly the DSA wants different things, like defunding the police and the military, and nationalizing major sectors of the economy, and rewriting the Constitution generally, and dismantling capitalism.

This is either grossly disingenuous on your part, or you're very bad at understanding things, or you're just confused about where you are.

"You like it when you have basic public services? Then logically you must want to nationalize the economy, by definition!"

Robert's avatar

You just keep revealing yourself as something very, very far from a liberal.

No serious candidate backs defunding the police, the military nor nationalizing major sectors of the economy. Rewriting the Constitution is a given desire but unlikely to happen. While dismantling capitalism is a bogeyman and nothing more.

You are quite dishonest, as is Mr. Yglesias, when pretending to care about liberalism while actually trying to put lipstick on MAGA and pretend it is prettier.

Xaide's avatar

To me there is what CRT proposed, and what it has done out in the wild. My experience of it in the social justice space and very progressive area is that it has often been misapplied and had negative effects. It has pathologized both whiteness and people of color, focusing on the bad, isolated and atomized us instead of forging a united path forward, and really reinforced and legitimized racism by making race THE most important thing and categorizing everyone according to racial stereotypes and generalizations. It has contributed to the oppressor/oppressed framework, it has often demonized whiteness and western culture while lionizing BIPOC cultures without acknowledging both the good and bad that come with ANY culture. I think ultimately it has done more harm than good, and the framework for POC - we are horribly oppressed, the most important thing about us is we are horribly oppressed, and anything going wrong in our lives is because of white people/racism - has been harmful and disempowering and inaccurate.

Glau Hansen's avatar

That's a pretty standard recitation of conservative claims about CRT, yeah.

Xaide's avatar

I don't know what the conservative claims about CRT are because I don't consume conservative media beyond the Economist and maybe the odd conservative opinion writer in the NYT. I'm talking about what I have seen in a very progressive field where equity and racism have been constant themes for the past 10 years. There have been some upsides: better awareness about things like redlining, unequal sentencing, etc., but by and large it has been a net negative, not the least because the backlash to it by conservatives has been so intense and so destructive that it has erased any modest gains that were gained during the intense focus on identity politics. We were busy calling the presence of Western protestant values "white supremacy" and actual white supremacists took over the country.

Robert's avatar

Well your description of the current state of affairs can’t be argued with. But you seem to be saying “we shouldn’t have hit them so hard, because they hit back.” Both liberalism and CRT require a lot more resolve than that.

Robert's avatar

That's the thing. I am white AF. Grew up in a lower middle class family in the heartland. And I don't feel pathologized. My grandfather was an early member of the John Birch Society. HE is pathologized by CRT? Sure. I don't do penance for my grandfather's sins (and he was the GOOD grandfather lol). In Hamburg Germany stand the ruins of a church that was destroyed by American bombing near the end of WWII. At one end is memorial for the residents of Hamburg who were killed in WWII. At the other end of the church is a memorial to the jews of Hamburg who were rounded up with the help of some of those people memorialized at the other end of the church. Go on. Ask a German today if they feel guilty about WWII. They don't. Because they are not like their predecessors (well most of them anyway).

If a white person feels like this is about THEM personally, well, maybe it is. Take a moment for that to settle in.

You are suggesting that a battered wife should "forge a united path forward" with her abuser when he hasn't even accepted the gravity of his actions. Today's vicious fascist backlash is the last gasps of a dying world order. It may go on for years, but it is the end.

Any impulse you have to "play nice" reflects well on you. But will not end well for you. If someone reacts negatively to "white guilt" it means you have struck a nerve. Until they can look that in eye and not be affected personally, you have to keep pushing.

Askewnaut's avatar

you seem hopelessly confused. crt is antithetical to liberalism. even if you knew nothing (seems possible) one hint is that no important thinker in the history of liberalism comes anywhere near saying anything resembling crt. not hobbes or locke, not rousseau, smith, mill, popper... another hint is that crt-ists literally tell you. at least some of them are intelligent enough to realize that what theyre saying directly contradicts liberalisms foundational premises and most important philosophical commitments - individualism (individuals cannot be understood apart from racial and institutional power), universalism (universal norms are defined by dominant groups), equality before the law (identical treatment perpetuates inequality), meritocracy, freedom... every load bearing premise of liberalism is smashed in service of race woowoo born of naked anxiety and envy. i can only conclude that you understand neither liberalism nor crt.

Robert's avatar

If you think that liberalism stopped developing in the Rennaisance, there is nothing I can do to help you until you get up to date. At some point you’ll come across CRT . . . in the early 1970s.

Chris's avatar

i pray to god you don’t have regular interactions with young people

Robert's avatar

You can pray all you want. It clearly has stopped school shootings, so who knows? Or you can accept the fact that when you enter a conversation with an ad hominem you are screaming "I AM CLUELESS" at the top of your lungs.

Chris's avatar

I suspect we lack the sufficient common understanding of reality to support conversation.

Robert's avatar

That is very grown up of you to admit.

Adam Johnson's avatar

This whole argument is older than this most recent manifestation. It’s really weird, though, that each side in this debate has become in reality the previous iteration’s opposition’s straw man.

On the right: “yup, we’re racist!”, and on the left: “yup, individuals are irrelevant!”.

It seems very odd.

NY Expat's avatar

I call this the “hold my beer” method of politics.

AI8706's avatar

I think this piece doesn't really try to get at the genesis of the argument in a way that does it justice. It's easy to say that "the way to stop discriminating on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race." That sounds nice, but doesn't reflect how people actually behave.

What frameworks like CRT do is force people to address the genesis of differences in representation. And those have to do with... ostensibly color-blind policies that in practice reflect broader society's biases. There are some ways that are incidental (much of American society, from college admissions through promotions, are built on old boys' networks that are heavily white and male, because society has long privileged white people and males. But there are also ways in which implicit biases shape outcomes.

Take ostensibly meritocratic institutions like law firms (which is the area I know best). Law schools and law firms were very good at recruiting underrepresented minorities. They were very bad at retaining and promoting them. Your white shoe law firm might dip deeper into the class at Columbia Or Penn law to hire a Black attorney, on the margin. But when they get to the firm, they're very likely to ask those attorneys to go to recruiting events on behalf of the firm (for which their time isn't credited), but aren't at all likely to bring those attorneys to client pitches or staff them on deals for the best clients (in part because those clients bristle, explicitly or implicitly, at Black attorneys being on their deal teams). When white junior attorneys made mistakes, they were treated as growing pains. When Black junior attorneys made mistakes, they were evidence that those attorneys weren't equipped to do the job. "We tried," senior attorneys would gripe, and then push those attorneys out.

And the solution to that probably isn't to pretend that we're being race-neutral. It also isn't to pretend that there aren't bad Black attorneys or that criticizing their performance is inherently racist. But it does mean taking seriously ways in which people ARE treated like members of groups rather than individuals, and figure out how to mitigate or eliminate those biases. This piece doesn't engage with any of that.

Steve Sailer's avatar

The rise of wokeness was pretty inevitable, at least following the 1994 backlash against "The Bell Curve." The conventional wisdom crystallized by three decades ago that it was unthinkable that the reasons for the documented average performance gaps between whites and black in IQ and crime simply couldn't be due to deep-rooted differences in European and sub-Saharan culture and/or genetics that evolved in the 50,000 or so years since the Out of Africa event.

No, it had to be the fault of whites since 1619. Therefore, American whites must pay.

The logic of the recent racial reckoning shakedown was relatively cast-iron: if any other explanation for the shortcomings on average of African-Americans relative to whites besides the moral guilt of whites is inconceivable, then the only possible explanation is that whites are guilty and must pay for their racist crimes.

PhillyT's avatar

> The conventional wisdom crystallized by three decades ago that it was unthinkable that the reasons for the documented average performance gaps between whites and black in IQ and crime simply couldn't be due to deep-rooted differences in European and sub-Saharan culture and/or genetics that evolved in the 50,000 or so years since the Out of Africa event.

I originally wasn't going to comment on this, but an IQ test is a standard exam and when you control for zip code or socioeconomic status across decades the gap between IQ or success narrows significantly. On your comment about crime, I think it is less about deep rooted differences in culture and genetics and again more about status and how things are policed. Maybe I'm taking your comments about fixed biology out of context but I'm a bit confused.

I've never been one of those people who thinks everything goes back to 1619 or white people being evil, but I'm not sure if you sincerely believe this eugenics stuff or you were being flippant. But when you track socioeconomic status and family / housing stability over decades the gap between crime and cognitive ability is almost imperceivable. You could also look at the Flynn effect that shows cognitive ability and test scores rises substantially in industrialized societies. That isn't a genetic mutation... There is absolutely upward mobility at the individual and group level when socioeconomic conditions improve for people. I definitely think the impact of Jim Crow impacted the Black Community, however I think blaming race for modern day issues is a cop out. Both things can be true.

For instance, if someone from 1900 took a modern IQ test normalized today, their average score would sit around 70-75 which is the threshold for intellectual disability. Conversely, a person of average intelligence today taking a test from 1920 would score around 120-130. So I'm not sure why you seemed to be stuck on deep rooted differences between Europe and sub-Saharan Africa and genetics, or 50k years of evolution when its been proven time and time again that homosapiens across the world really aren't that different when it comes to cognitive ability or the crime when all things are equal.

Steve Sailer's avatar

It's widely assumed that racial/ethnic differences in crime rates can be statistically adjusted away, but few people bother look at the huge gap in homicide victimization rates between blacks and Hispanics, even though they tend to average fairly similar on socio-economic measures.

From 2018-2025, according the CDC WONDER mortality database, black males age 15-34 died by homicide at an annual rate of 97.1 per 100,000, while Hispanic males of the same ages died at a rate of 17.3.

In other words, young black men died by homicide (typically at the hands of other young black men) 5.6 times as often per capita as young Hispanic men died by homicide.

That black vs. Latino homicide ratio is crazy, but practically nobody in America is aware of how big it has gotten in this century.

The Hispanic homicide victimization rate has fallen since the 2008 Crash, but few people give them credit for it.

PhillyT's avatar

You didn't really answer my question and seem to be moving the goalposts a bit. As a mixed race person (black + white), I'm very familiar with crime in the black community and you seem to be shifting from your original statement of 50k years of evolution creating certain groups that have higher levels of education + crime that is tied to their cognitive behavior, now to general demographic crime disparities between black / hispanic males.

You created a strawman to argue with, I never said that the black community didn't have higher rates of violent crime or was trying to compare them to the hispanic community. You are now attempting to give credit to just their community being better than the black community, and not the fact that we as America do well as a whole when people assimilate and achieve better economic outcomes seems a bit short sighted...

Going back to my original point, when you look at communities with stable economic foundations, low poverty, and strong neighborhood resources, crime rates drop significantly regardless of race, because local environmental and economic conditions are usually the primary drivers of those outcomes.

Further, if you looked at the 1800's to early 1900's you'd be saying similar things rhetoric wise against Irish and Italians that you are now saying about black people they had higher rates of violent crime back then than black people. Crime rates in general declined from the 1990's - 2015 time frame, and again economic progress and generational stability has a huge impact on crime and education. Over that time, we've seen the Hispanic / Latino community in America edge slightly ahead of Black people.

Progress on crime and education is shaped a lot less by whatever eugenics and culture framework you originally led with and more about economics, education, community, generational wealth and family stability. Address the original point, no need to start comparing Hispanic males vs black males, if anything it doesn't help prove your point that cognitive ability or crime are just so fixed after 50k years…

Steve Sailer's avatar

Thanks.

Unfortunately, there are many common misunderstandings about what drives homicides and traffic fatality trends. They tend to move the opposite of Case and Deaton's Deaths of Despair (suicides, opioid overdoses, alcoholism). Homicide and car crash deaths tend to be Deaths of Exuberance that go down when times are tough, like after 2008, and explode when the government is sending out stimmy checks and declaring you don't have to pay rent.

These Deaths of Exuberance especially go up for a race when everybody who is anybody is declaring that it's time for a "racial reckoning" because they have been victims since 1619 and that therefore the police should stop being so mean to them and not pull them over for bad driving and search them for illegal handguns so much, as we saw both times Black Lives Matter was riding high, the Ferguson Effect and the Floyd Effect, and both black homicide victimizations and black traffic fatalities soared. The Floyd Effect, in particular, was astonishing, with black deaths by homicide increasing 44% from 2019 to 2021 and black deaths by traffic accident increasing 39%, with much of the increase concentrated in a few weeks following George Floyd's death on May 25, 2020.

Rick Gore's avatar

My over-simplified understanding of CRT is basically: “sure, you can have well intentioned laws and legal norms that seek to protect minorities but when push really comes to shove people are tribal and these protections will get ignored and minorities trampled.” I don’t like CRT because I think it’s pretty bleak but there is no question there is plenty of evidence to support this CRT view and for that reason alone it absolutely belongs in the academy as a legitimate theory for debate and discussion.

The problem I see with CRT is it being pulled out of the academy and somehow informing activism, which strikes me as a dead end. If you take CRT seriously what advice does it have for a racial, ethnic or religious minority living amidst other, much larger groups? Basically: Israel or Pakistan- that it is foolish to depend on the rule of law to protect you (the tribe rules all) so you need to be where the tribe is strong. So move to where you will be the majority, as many Jews did after the creation of Israel. Alternatively, if you have enough political power, create a partition of your state with your piece leaving your tribe as dominant (Pakistan).

But nobody wants to do THOSE things so the CRT inspiration is to try to effect tribal based preferences (for everyone BUT the largest tribe- which is clearly unsustainable) or just attempts to manipulate language and the culture- which ended up just pissing a lot of people off without actually making any material gains. It’s not clear at all that these half-hearted CRT inspired actions lead to a better place for minorities than just pushing for actual, well-implemented liberalism.

Falous's avatar

I do not think there is any doubt that CRT and its identarian focus has lead to much worse outcomes than pursuit of actual liberal society.

Referencing CRT for cases like Pakistan or Israel is a full out category error: achievement of some evolution to more liberal society as More Identity does lead to nice and better places, the opposite really.

One has only need to look back to real history - as like transition of the Ottoman society to see CRT is about as useful as Soviet New Man theories.

Nor does CRT stand up to good solid evidence - the positive evolution of American society against starting point, say pre-Civil Rights era shows that clealry. no magic wands exist certainly

Shreeharsh Kelkar's avatar

I am a big fan of this piece. It's worthwhile to point out also that even Charles Mills who played a role in the development of critical race theory through his book "The Racial Contract" also ended up, near the end of his life, advocating for liberalism, a liberalism that is more sensitive to inequality, perhaps, but where individual rights are still prior to groups. https://www.pdcnet.org/pdc/bvdb.nsf/purchase26?openform&fp=radphilrev&id=radphilrev_2012_0015_0002_0305_0323

Testname's avatar

Missed this article the first time around, thanks for the repost.

James Gillen's avatar

A microaggression is sort of like a micropenis. If you can barely perceive it, it doesn't really count.

Glau Hansen's avatar

Tell that to ask the people taking the phrase "white cis men" as an attack on them personally.

PhillyT's avatar

Or the people who even take the compliment Big Dick Energy (BDE) personally. It is so weird.

James Gillen's avatar

Well, there's a difference between having a big dick and BEING a big dick.

James Gillen's avatar

It's only an attack if you perceive it that way.

Adam Buchbinder's avatar

Are you actually proposing they're that the people complaining about microaggressions aren't actually doing microaggressions against men?

Do you need me to find you a sample? I'm sure it's behind my "male tears" mug somewhere.

Method3000's avatar

Okay but don't we agree that Indigenous People's Day is better than Columbus Day? Or just get rid of the holiday or call it Americas day or something. Columbus was a terrible person even by the standards of his time. If you pass over in silence points like this in your lust to condemn bad leftists it can make you seem... illiberal.

PhillyT's avatar

I always thought it should just be named after America Vespucci.. You know the guy who actually named America and wasn't a piece of trash? America Day would be great and could be inclusive of everyone. Just my 2 cents.

Steve Sailer's avatar

Rename it "Columbia Exchange Day" and everybody celebrates it by eating pizza, made with Old World cheese and wheat and New World tomatoes.

Dave's avatar

We honestly shouldn’t have the holiday. Columbus Day was an affirmative action holiday for Italian immigrants and their descendants. But the children of Irish, German, Jewish, Japanese, etc. immigrants don’t get a holiday, and Columbus isn’t really that important. Columbus never made it to North America. John Cabot was first to do that. Columbus never realized there was a whole new continent there. Vespucci was the first to do that. Columbus also never touched the continental USA mainland. Ponce de Leon was the first to do that.

We only have national holidays celebrating a historical figure’s birth for four people: Martin Luther King Jr., George Washington, Jesus of Nazareth, and Christopher Columbus. Of those four, I think King is probably the least historically significant globally, but Columbus is clearly the least important to the USA specifically.

Miles's avatar

Great to reread this! One thing it got me pondering... I do have doubts that the individual is the best unit for most analyses. Group identities are incredibly important. But I don't think they are exclusively ethnic or racial, and people have many identities, some stronger and some weaker.

I think a lab-perfect liberalism might underestimate the group identity impact.

Ted Swing's avatar

Can you relate that to specific examples such as those Yglesias gives here? If one makes social groups the unit of analysis and reducing inequality the goal, it logically follows to take steps to worsen the quality of public education for white students, for example, or to eliminate testing that reveals group disparities, and promote alternative methods for selecting/elevating students based on racial/ethnic group identity and the perception of those groups as oppressor vs. oppressed, rather than qualities specific to an individual applicant. I tend to think that these policies are a bad thing and agree with Yglesias that it doesn't actually make any individuals better off. Substituting a different group identity (other than race/ethnicity) doesn't make it any better. I don't want to assume that's what you're saying, but without reference to specific cases/issues, I really can't tell.

Miles's avatar

I'm not going for the full oppressor/oppressed setup, but more like the "what's the matter with Kansas" point that people seem to make policy decisions beyond their individual interests.

I'm a well credentialed person who aligns with "experts" and that can form my opinions more than personal incentive. But also, I'm from a rural community so I have an identity that cares for rural concerns even though they are no longer my own direct concerns. In local politics, I am in a suburb where the tension is between old-timers and new arrivals, and I side with the latter as a group on issues where I might not individually have an opinion.

An analysis that only looks at my individual interests won't understand why I support free trade in services, gun rights, or bike lanes. Those things aren't really for me, they are for the groups I identify with.

Ted Swing's avatar

Thanks. I appreciate the clarification. It seems like it's not necessarily a difference of positions as a difference of what level of human experience one is focused on. My sense is that the classical liberal focus on the individual is more at the level of where society establishes/implements institutional policies. The idea, as I understand it, is that those rules should not extend or withhold rights based on which group identity(ies) the person holds. It seems totally fine, normal, and compatible with classical liberalism for people to have their opinions/policy views shaped by their own group identities, as in the example you give.

Chuan's avatar

I still remember in one of my first college class, a rather famous Dutch professor asked a girl in class "where are you from". The girl said New Jersey. And the Duct professor kept asking "where are you really from". And the girl finally answered "Shanghai". And the confusing part is, I'd rather say I'm from Shanghai than NJ.

blake harper's avatar

So much more can and needs to be said about the influence of critical theory on the left's moral psychology and ideological furniture, but I think the single most valuable thing I can offer Argument readers in a comment is a search term they can hand to their favorite LLMs for lit review. That term is — Left wing authoritarianism (LWA).

There are robust social scientific results describing the argumentative dispositions, attitudes towards political violence, etc. that are predicted by ones proclivity towards LWA and that predict ones support for different left-progressive causes.

Will you hear about LWA on NPR? Or in the NYT? Or in your NESCAC / Ivy undergrad lecture? Probably not. And therein lies the problem. The sooner we can collectively recognize and differentiate left-authoritarianism from left-liberalism the sooner we'll be able to resuscitate the Democratic party's brand and stop the reaction-formation that gives the political right all its authoritarian energy. Remember, we (the left) struck first — and we have more social capital, so we have to be the ones to de-escalate, recant, and re-direct. It's not the party that initiates a political revolution that sets its durable terms (in the Gary Gerstle sense); it's the opposition party who defines what the acceptable bounds of that new revolution are (Clinton is to Reagan as Eisenhower is to FDR as ____ democratic president is to Trump).

Relevant literature:

- https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1794108/full

- https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/10.1111/pops.12951

Wayne Karol's avatar

I like to call this sort of thing "Costanza politics". If traditional forms of oppression required "people of color" to be submissive to whites, the answer is to do the opposite: require whites to be submissive to them. Same for men and women, straights and gays...

Galt's avatar

I was taught about CRT in the seminar of an undergraduate education course at UCLA in roughly 2014. I thought there were a couple pretty important takeaways. 1) it does white people who’ve never thought about what being white means to think about that, 2) understanding the equity critique of supposed meritocracy when people start on different starting lines is a useful concept to know, and 3) a lot of systems that are ostensibly race-neutral work to perpetuate existing disparities. And this one I learned later, but 4) our government has played a role in causing a good amount of this disparity in the first place through directly discriminatory treatment (think redlining, racial lending, practices of southern states during Jim Crow, not to mention of course actual slavery and that slaves didn’t get reparations).

The problem with these ideas is that they are extremely open ended and people from all across the spectrum can take them to completely illogical places with a justification that can sound half-plausible if it’s coming across through normal internet/social-media style communication. I personally think the carefully considered moderate approach is best here, but it’s not totally unreasonable to be strongly for or against these things just as a matter of personal interest, status in society, economic benefit/harm, etc. Most people aren’t concerned with carefully following the principles of liberalism all the time, especially on social media and with internet anonymity.

Glau Hansen's avatar

...it does seem, then, like you are isolated from the things identity politics was trying to address, so it would make sense why you only saw negative outcomes.

Consuming some conservative media, and occasionally reading the comments, makes it very clear why CRT is a useful frame of analysis and what identity politics is actually doing.