This kind of stuff makes it difficult to hold on to the principle that we're all fellow citizens debating best policy and even in deeply contentious social issues the disagreement comes out of whose competing interests we are most trying to protect.
Because "we should murder people and take possessions to enrich ourselves" is pretty evil. I don't really know where to go with that discussion.
What the big flip in polling around ‘international involvement’ reveals to me is a shift in the concept grammar of the term - under Bush, for conservatives, it was ‘projection of power towards American moral and strategic aims’ and for liberals was ‘broad expansionary interventionism’; now, for conservatives, it’s ’subsuming American interests to sets of external obligations’ whereas for liberals it’s ’participation in a normative global order’.
The thing I think is being lost is the general idea that the eighty-year inertia of the broadly construed global international institutional order *intrinsically favors America in its game design*. One does not need to compute a given ‘international system’ transaction W/L balance at the object level because the overall design is so advantageous to us.
Yeah, but the percent of the population that understands this is what, 10%? Even that might be generous. Everyone else is just taking for granted the way life is, and they both lack the knowledge and the imagination capacity to understand what the alternatives look like.
The thing that strikes me is that Democratic voters appear also to have turned their backs on liberal internationalism, a fairly fundamental tenet of which is that you honor your treaty obligations. In your polling, a minority of Democrats agree that the US should act in support of an ally with which it has a defense treaty; and that includes NATO allies (ie the central security institution of post-war Western liberal internationalism).
This is kind of shocking. We have been told by respectable outlets like the New York Times that Trump's base has soured on him because of Iran, $6 diesel and all that, never mind that Democrats not to long ago were advocating higher taxes on carbon. Are they wrong? Is Trump's base, and Republicans in general still with him on Iran? Is Trump once again being underestimated?
Another thing is that the GOP's preferences are misguided. In fact, the US does not have the strength it thinks it has. After WW II the US did rebuild Europe to keep Europeans from voting in Communists, and it worked. Democratic president Harry Truman and people like MacArthur thought we could drive the North Koreans back to China. We could not and had to settle for a truce and backing South Korean dictators. Democratic president Lyndon Johnson thought the same about Vietnam and we lost. Republican George W Bush thought Iraq would be easy, based on the success of driving Hussein out of Kuwait. Hussein was defeated in Iraq and then Bush tried to do what Truman did in Europe after WW II. It did not work. As Matt Yglesias has pointed out, Afghanistan was a defeat because Republican Bush and Democrat Obama wasted resources on Iraq.
We have limits. The biggest restraint is public opinion. The public does not favor losing American lives in pointless wars. Trump still has support in Iran because few American lives are being lost, bu that cannot last forever. We are running out of hardware. We cannot defend Taiwan and China knows it. We cannot help Ukraine and Putin knows it. This is an extremely dangerous situation.
This kind of stuff makes it difficult to hold on to the principle that we're all fellow citizens debating best policy and even in deeply contentious social issues the disagreement comes out of whose competing interests we are most trying to protect.
Because "we should murder people and take possessions to enrich ourselves" is pretty evil. I don't really know where to go with that discussion.
What the big flip in polling around ‘international involvement’ reveals to me is a shift in the concept grammar of the term - under Bush, for conservatives, it was ‘projection of power towards American moral and strategic aims’ and for liberals was ‘broad expansionary interventionism’; now, for conservatives, it’s ’subsuming American interests to sets of external obligations’ whereas for liberals it’s ’participation in a normative global order’.
The thing I think is being lost is the general idea that the eighty-year inertia of the broadly construed global international institutional order *intrinsically favors America in its game design*. One does not need to compute a given ‘international system’ transaction W/L balance at the object level because the overall design is so advantageous to us.
Yeah, but the percent of the population that understands this is what, 10%? Even that might be generous. Everyone else is just taking for granted the way life is, and they both lack the knowledge and the imagination capacity to understand what the alternatives look like.
The thing that strikes me is that Democratic voters appear also to have turned their backs on liberal internationalism, a fairly fundamental tenet of which is that you honor your treaty obligations. In your polling, a minority of Democrats agree that the US should act in support of an ally with which it has a defense treaty; and that includes NATO allies (ie the central security institution of post-war Western liberal internationalism).
A lot of people never mentally leave high school domination rituals.
This is kind of shocking. We have been told by respectable outlets like the New York Times that Trump's base has soured on him because of Iran, $6 diesel and all that, never mind that Democrats not to long ago were advocating higher taxes on carbon. Are they wrong? Is Trump's base, and Republicans in general still with him on Iran? Is Trump once again being underestimated?
Another thing is that the GOP's preferences are misguided. In fact, the US does not have the strength it thinks it has. After WW II the US did rebuild Europe to keep Europeans from voting in Communists, and it worked. Democratic president Harry Truman and people like MacArthur thought we could drive the North Koreans back to China. We could not and had to settle for a truce and backing South Korean dictators. Democratic president Lyndon Johnson thought the same about Vietnam and we lost. Republican George W Bush thought Iraq would be easy, based on the success of driving Hussein out of Kuwait. Hussein was defeated in Iraq and then Bush tried to do what Truman did in Europe after WW II. It did not work. As Matt Yglesias has pointed out, Afghanistan was a defeat because Republican Bush and Democrat Obama wasted resources on Iraq.
We have limits. The biggest restraint is public opinion. The public does not favor losing American lives in pointless wars. Trump still has support in Iran because few American lives are being lost, bu that cannot last forever. We are running out of hardware. We cannot defend Taiwan and China knows it. We cannot help Ukraine and Putin knows it. This is an extremely dangerous situation.
60% support is perfectly compatible with losing nearly half of his past voters because of this!
Great piece.