Discussion about this post

User's avatar
StrangePolyhedrons's avatar

This kind of stuff makes it difficult to hold on to the principle that we're all fellow citizens debating best policy and even in deeply contentious social issues the disagreement comes out of whose competing interests we are most trying to protect.

Because "we should murder people and take possessions to enrich ourselves" is pretty evil. I don't really know where to go with that discussion.

Zac Hill's avatar

What the big flip in polling around ‘international involvement’ reveals to me is a shift in the concept grammar of the term - under Bush, for conservatives, it was ‘projection of power towards American moral and strategic aims’ and for liberals was ‘broad expansionary interventionism’; now, for conservatives, it’s ’subsuming American interests to sets of external obligations’ whereas for liberals it’s ’participation in a normative global order’.

The thing I think is being lost is the general idea that the eighty-year inertia of the broadly construed global international institutional order *intrinsically favors America in its game design*. One does not need to compute a given ‘international system’ transaction W/L balance at the object level because the overall design is so advantageous to us.

6 more comments...

Ready for more?